Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
The New Yorker Sandwich
The Super Sontzy Sandwich
Corned Beef Rachel Sandwich
Corned Beef Reuben Sandwich
About
Evan's New York Style Deli
Welcome to Evan's New York Style Deli, a hidden gem nestled in Marblehead, Massachusetts. Located at 252 Humphrey St, this deli captures the essence of the Big Apple with its tempting menu offerings and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Seamlessly blending quality ingredients with time-honored recipes, Evan's has quickly become a local favorite for both breakfast and lunch.
As you step inside, you might notice that the decor lacks the pretentiousness of upscale establishments, but it certainly makes up for it with the charm and friendliness of its staff. Customers often rave about their experience, like Frank Gayton, who exclaimed, "What this deli lacks in genteel atmosphere, it more than makes up for in friendly service and terrific food!"
Evan's menu is a voyage through classic deli fare, with standout offerings such as:
- Bagels: Indulge in a traditional Bagel with Cream Cheese for just $3.00, or savor the Bagel with Lox Mix for $6.65.
- Club Sandwiches: The Romanian Pastrami Sandwich is a must-try at $25.95, boasting tender, flavorful meat that has left customers like Beth O' singing its praises.
- Specialty Sandwiches: Don’t miss the Mixed Marriage sandwich, an exquisite blend of brisket, bacon, and fresh veggies, served on an onion roll — a personal favorite for many.
The attention to quality and detail is evident in every bite. The pastrami, for instance, has been likened to some of the best offerings in New York City, reaffirming its place in the deli hall of fame. As Matthew Peterson noted, Evan’s is "definitely a local landmark," and one taste will reveal why.
If you’re new to the deli scene or just passing through, you won’t want to overlook this culinary treasure. It’s a place where hearty meals and friendly conversations flourish, making every visit an adventure worth embarking on. Come for the sandwiches, stay for the camaraderie, and leave with a full belly and a smile.
So, whether it's your first time or you're a regular, Evan's New York Style Deli promises a delightful experience you won't soon forget.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I have passed this building for years and never paid attention to what was inside. I wont make that mistake again! What this deli lacks in genteel atmosphere, it more than makes up for in friendly service and terrific food! Dont miss the chopped liver!!! ”
“ Was driving by at just past 10 am with a hungry belly, figured Why not, its Friday. 2 very nice ladies were behind the counter, and a few folks in line. I was asked if I was ready to order, and was let known breakfast or lunch is not a problem. I went with the Mixed Marriage sandwich. This beauty had the meats, brisket, bacon, ham, and some veggies with a horseradish sauce on an onion roll. Sandwich was a thing of beauty, well made, not too messy, and quality ingredients in proper proportions. The only critique I have is the pickle was a bit lack luster. I wish I took a picture, but I wasnt expecting a sandwich with brisket to be that good at 10am. I plan to stop and try more specialty sandwiches if I am in the area again, and recommend anyone reading this review do the same. Evans Deli has the meats! ”
“ I am over the top to find high quality pastrami that can compete with a NY deli. Their Romanian pastrami is great tender and flavorful. Lots of accompaniments, rolls, rye bread to round it out. You can get a sandwich or order cold cuts to go. Small take out with a few tables. Trust me on the pastrami! ”
“ We went here because they were close to our new home, and we were not disappointed. They gave us some great sandwiches and great knishes. The owner was also friendly and welcoming. If you havent tried Evans, I would recommend giving them a shot. Because its definitely a local landmark! ”
“ Evans New York Style Deli is amazing!!!!!!! I recommend their sandwich The Mixed Marriage, The Champion, and Evans Choice. I f you are visiting the area or live here, GO HERE! Some of their amenities include nice friendly staff, freshly cooked food, and great decoration. ”
“ Spectacular Sandwiches Reubans were spectacular. So delicious. Later that night we had two sandwiches that we saved for next day a turkey and pastrami they we unbelievably great. The girls behind counter were a pleasure. Evan you have a great business here. Cant wait to return. While I waited I had a bagel ....so good !!! Ten stars to you all !!!!! ”
“ Oh ... my .... Goodness!!! We treated ourselves to a morning delivery of bagels and knishes and it was amazingly good!!! If you havent tried their or anyones knishes, you really should treat yourselves. I had the pastrami knish and the brisket knish. Both are delicious fistfuls of classic NY Deli meats in a light pastry basically its handheld beef bbq without the sauce. Such a luxury! Evans is now our go to for delicious deli on the North Shore! Also a big shout out to Salem 104.9 FM for broadcasting from Evans NY Deli over the holidays that how I learned about this great deli just a few blocks from the MHD historic district ”
“ Ordered a reuben. Biggest, most delicious sandwich ever. And thank heavens they used Russian, not thousand island. They were busy, phone ringing, people in line. But the guy behind the counter kept it moving. Super courteous, with amazing food. I wish I lived closer to Marblehead! ”